Whitepapers & Learning
Learning paperVersion 1.0

Making Community Visible: What Our Directories Reveal

A cross-portfolio audit of community groups, local facilities and second-hand discovery

Published 11 November 2026 CommuniTees and ThriftMap Aggregate anonymous data only

How to read this

A cross-platform descriptive data audit. Two directories have different geographic scopes, so their counts cannot be combined into a single local coverage rate.

382
approved community listings
CommuniTees, five Tees Valley areas
309
mapped community listings
Approved listings with coordinates
3,168
reuse and second-hand records
ThriftMap, UK-wide
2,862
verified active stores
Stored ThriftMap status, not a visit audit

Findable does not always mean verified or accessible

73 approved CommuniTees entries lack coordinates, and 306 ThriftMap records are not currently marked both active and verified. A directory listing is not evidence that somebody attended, donated, reused an item or saved carbon.

Public-data rule: this page contains no participant names, emails, account identifiers or respondent IDs.

A cross-portfolio audit of community groups, local facilities and second-hand discovery

Publication: 11 November 2026 | Type: Community infrastructure data audit | Status: Descriptive learning paper, not peer-reviewed research.

Executive summary

Community participation depends partly on a basic practical question: can people find somewhere to go? The same is true of reuse and second-hand services. Two Here/Now portfolio platforms address different parts of that challenge: CommuniTees surfaces community organisations and activities across the Tees Valley, while ThriftMap helps people locate second-hand and reuse places over a much wider UK geography.

At the 11 November 2026 snapshot, CommuniTees contained 430 listings, of which 382 were approved. Of the approved set, 309 had latitude and longitude, leaving 73 without coordinates. The records span five Tees Valley local authority areas.

ThriftMap contained 3,168 store records, of which 2,862 were marked verified and active. Another 276 required review, 28 were labelled invalid and two closed. All store records had stored coordinates, but coordinates do not guarantee a site is open, accurate or suitable for every visitor.

The directories have made thousands of places administratively findable. Whether that translates into equitable access, stronger communities or fewer goods going to waste requires a different measurement approach.

Purpose and research question

How complete and reliable are the portfolio's two place-discovery datasets, and which measurable steps would establish their contribution to community accessibility and environmental action?

Data and method

This audit queried the full CommuniTees Listing table (430 records) and ThriftMap Store table (3,168 records, retrieved in seven paginated batches) through read-only Base44 entity access on 11 November 2026.

CommuniTees statistics count approved records separately from pending and rejected entries. Mapping completeness uses the presence of numeric latitude and longitude in approved listings. Area breakdowns follow the recorded Tees Valley area labels.

ThriftMap statistics count all stored locations and group them by verification_status and is_active. A store is described here as 'verified active' only if both corresponding stored fields support that label. The audit does not independently telephone, visit or browse each listing. No join was performed across the products because their areas, categories and deduplication methods differ.

Environmental impact values were deliberately not summed. The field co2_saved_kg is filled in 207 store records, but this audit did not establish a common, measured basis or transaction-level evidence for those estimates.

Findings

CommuniTees: community access infrastructure

The 382 approved records are distributed as follows:

  • Stockton-on-Tees: 138
  • Middlesbrough: 87
  • Redcar & Cleveland: 66
  • Hartlepool: 48
  • Darlington: 43

The largest listed categories include village halls and community centres (107), general listings (58), services/help/support (57), charities/social enterprises (45) and sports/games/fitness (43). These labels describe the published inventory, not an independent census of all provision.

Of 382 approved listings, 309 have coordinates. The stored geocoding-status field marks 306 as 'ok', 41 as 'needs_review', 34 as 'missing' and one as 'failed'. These statuses are not fully interchangeable with whether coordinate fields are populated. Source URLs are present on 379 approved records and website URLs on 374.

ThriftMap: circular-economy discovery

The 3,168 records include 2,748 in the broad charity category, 189 furniture, 109 vintage, 46 second-hand, 45 community hubs, 30 reuse and one recycling. Categories are not proof that stock, opening times or accepted donations are consistent.

Of the records, 2,862 are stored as verified and active; 276 require review, 28 are invalid and two closed. All 3,168 contain latitude and longitude. A source URL is present for 2,877 records. The dataset is UK-wide, so it must not be described as 3,168 Tees Valley locations.

Why the two counts are not added together

The inventories have different boundaries, definitions and update processes. Organisations may have multiple sites, and one place may appear in more than one directory. Adding the counts would wrongly imply a deduplicated total of facilities.

What these findings mean

The main value demonstrated is structured availability: more community and reuse information has been organised and exposed through purpose-built discovery tools. That is a meaningful prerequisite for participation, but it is not the final impact.

The data-quality gaps are also revealing. A missing coordinate can prevent map use or route planning. An unchecked opening time can waste a journey. Poor category consistency can make search less useful, while a directory that overlooks low-income areas or accessibility information could inadvertently reinforce unequal access. In a future evaluation, successful discovery and verified use matter more than a raw listing count.

Limitations and safeguards

A listing can be outdated, duplicated, wrongly categorised, inaccessible or not publicly available at the recorded times. Stored 'verified' status does not establish the date, method or reliability of every verification. The geographic coverage of CommuniTees and ThriftMap differs fundamentally, preventing a combined coverage rate. Category totals reflect current app labels rather than an externally validated taxonomy.

This snapshot did not inspect business opening hours individually, test walking routes, analyse actual user journeys or check whether people acted on the listings. No measured donation weights, reused-item transactions or independently justified carbon conversion factors were audited. Therefore no carbon savings, waste reduction, wellbeing benefit or added participation can be claimed from these counts.

Practical recommendations

  1. Prioritise the 73 approved CommuniTees listings without coordinates for map and accessibility review.
  2. Prioritise ThriftMap's 306 non-verified-active records for appropriate review rather than public impact counting.
  3. Make verification dates, official source links, accessibility attributes, opening times and change-reporting prominent.
  4. Track aggregate search-to-click, route-planning and 'was this useful?' signals, excluding bots and protecting visitor privacy.
  5. Compare directory coverage with local need and underserved geographies, not simply the volume of entries.
  6. For environmental reporting, use audited reuse transactions or credible published conversion methods with clear uncertainty rather than unverified location-level CO₂ values.
  7. Establish a common evidence dictionary for community discovery so both platforms can report quality consistently without pretending their audiences or boundaries are identical.

Reproducibility and next review

Source: CommuniTees Listing and ThriftMap Store entity snapshots, 11 November 2026. Counts should be reproduced from the same status conditions and recorded area/category fields. Any updated review should publish the verification rules, duplicate-handling method and a repeatable geographic boundary before making coverage claims.

Source and privacy note

Aggregated read-only source records from CommuniTees Listing (430 rows) and ThriftMap Store (3,168 rows), 11 November 2026. The two apps cover different geographies. No contact details, user journeys or personal records were transferred.

here / now / today ltd · Studies & learning

This platform supports service evaluation and research workflows. It does not turn exploratory data into clinical evidence by magic. Methods, sample and limitations still matter.